How many different services and advertising channels can you pack into one television? HITEC in Austin provided us with dozens of vendors that seek to make money through televisions installed in hotel rooms.
And, most of it is just garbage. At least, that’s what the Marriott hoteliers are telling us.
These vendors are trying to feed advertising, hotel information and paid content through the primary entertainment device. For the most part, their value proposition is poor. The television can’t carry all of those businesses. Unfortunately, it is an easy target for expanded services simply because it already exists in every room and tapping into an unused channel is too tempting for vendors.
The problem with TV content providers is that people aren’t looking for information there. When a business traveler turns on the TV, they are heading toward a specific channel or program. So what if Lodgenet is the default channel to pop up? They are one remote control click away from being invisible and irrelevant. Usage and linger rates show that Lodgenet appeals to a very, very small subset of travelers overall. Some people check their bill on the TV. Others order the occasional movie. But, about 98% of hotel guests flip right past those information channels and never return.
These vendors suffer from the same problem that all of those sponsor-driven internet access sites experience; the kind that immediately take the user to the sponsor’s screen upon logging in. When I head to the internet, I’m likely headed there for a purpose (check email, sports, maps, etc…). When the sponsor screen pops up, I don’t even see it. I’m headed toward my destination and that sponsor screen isn’t even a speed bump along the way. When I turn on my laptop, I’ have a purpose and that’s where I’m going.
Same thing with Lodgenet and the other hotel service guides that feed through the television. When I turn on the TV in the hotel room, even if I don’t know the specific channel to watch, I know I’m looking for entertainment and channels that sell me stuff are rarely entertaining.
The best chance I saw at HITEC was a couple of companies that provide scrolling television programming guides. They have timed the guides to take a while and the most appealing stations are always at the end of the list. While the guide scrolls, advertisements are shown. Because they provide useful information, they have the highest likelihood of attracting eyeballs for a few minutes each day. (For an entertaining conversation, call HotelGuide and ask them how they feel about the fact that EGSTV guys broke off and formed a competing service. Three words: “Bitter Cat Fights.”)
In the next couple of posts, I’ll give my thoughts on the proper place for providing information and putting advertising in front of hotel guests.
In the meantime, happy traveling.
